Saturday, January 3, 2009

What's in a Name?

Many of my friends from both high school and college became teachers. At all levels, elementary, middle, and high. I taught too, though I taught at a university in Manhattan. I remember once mentioning this to a man I met at a party. Not that my friends had become teachers, but that I had taught in Manhattan.

"How long'd you live in Kansas?" he asked.
"No, not Kansas."
"I think you'll find Manhattan is in Kansas."
"Yes. There is a city called Manhattan in Kansas. But I'm talking about Manhattan in New York."
"Is that anywhere near Buffalo? I got kin in Buffalo."
"No, it's not by Buffalo. It's part of New York City."
"Son," this was not my father, nor even a father figure, but I guess I was a son figure. He continued, "Son, New York City is the name of the city."
I quickly decided using the word 'borough' would only confuse things further. "Right, but one part of New York City is an island."
"Right, Long Island. Heard of it."
"Yes, well, Long Island... A different part of it is an island called Manhattan."
"Manhattan is an island?" He was fascinated by this.
"Yes."
"On a lake? I didn't know Kansas had big lakes."
"No, no," I said. "Not Kansas. New York. Look, next New Year's Eve watch the ball drop at Times Square. I'm sure whoever hosts it will say he's in Manhattan."
"I had no idea they dropped that ball in Kansas!"

Sometimes you just have to walk away. From Kansas.

My friends who are teachers, coincidentally none of whom are in Kansas, sometimes complain about the crazy names that parents give their children. Unique. I don't mean unique names. I mean the name Unique. Or Jade, but apparently it isn't pronounced Jade, it's "Zhah-day" like a French "j" and two syllables. My friends think they are so put upon, being forced to pronounce and learn these names.

They've stopped crying to me about this, because I think they're being babies. Grow up. It's a big world. I had students from Asia, Europe, Africa, and South America. (I would have said all over the globe, but I don't recall ever having a student from Australia. Or Antarctica, but that goes without saying.) The names I had to learn make Zhah-day simplicity itself. There were thirteen letter names on the roster which had only one vowel and it was the last letter. There were names with letters apparently meant to be silent, though one could only know that after being corrected for making them unsilent. And there were many a student who said something like, "You're never going to get it. Just call me Bonnie."

We no longer live in a world where names are limited to Rebecca, Ronald, Robert, and Richard. People who like those names should, by all means, use them when naming their own children. Fill the planet up with Beckies, and Rons, and Bobs, and Dicks. But for those who want to go a little further afield, like me, we're in good company.

I did follow this rule: The name choices for both boy and girl were secret, shared only between my wife and myself. Because everyone has an opinion. And almost everyone's opinion is that new parents are choosing terrible names. Whatever they pick isn't what the opinion giver would have picked and must therefore be ridiculed. Or if it is what they would have picked, they must discourage the parents from using it so they don't seem like copycats when they use the name for any future children. Or more likely future child. Hopefully they don't name all of their children the same thing. Very confusing.

When my wife was pregnant with our first child, I didn't want to know if it was a boy or a girl. Well, I wanted to know once it was born. But not before. My wife hated the idea of calling the baby "it." But I was hesitant to use "he" or to use "she". For a while we used "he or she". My wife's grandmother found this offensive. She explained that "he" is perfectly correct for use as a pronoun for an unknown gender. I explained that my reasoning behind "he or she" was not grammatical, but psychological. I didn't want to think of the baby as one gender and then discover later it was another.

So we gave the baby a unisex to-be-used-while-in-the-womb name. We called our child Tadpole. One of the pregnancy books that tells you what your child looks like at each week describes a very early embryo as being vaguely like a tadpole. Good name, right! My father thought Tadpole was clearly a boy's name, because you could shorten it to Tad. I had to explain, more than once, that Tadpole wasn't the baby's name. It was just what we were calling it until birth.

So, naturally, every time I spoke to my parents, my father pestered me to know what names we had picked for boys and girls. But using my own principle above, I refused to tell them. I decided, instead, to have fun with it. I came up with the most outrageous names to use as my "newest idea" each time we talked.

"Well, if it's a boy I'm going to call him Archimedes."
"What!" my father would scream. "What kind of name is that?"
"Greek. Archimedes was a great Greek mathematician."
"You can't name your child Archi-whatever."

Or one week I told them that regardless of the gender I would name the child Mmiv. Tadpole was to be born in 2004, and the Roman numeral for 2004 is MMIV. You had to hold out the "m" sound twice as long, because there were two of them. It wasn't Miv, it was Mmiv.

At this my father was terrified that I was just going to make up some wretched sound and call it a name. So the next week I compromised with a biblical name: "Muppim."
"What?" my parents asked.
"It's a biblical name."
My mother said, "Not one of the better known biblical names."
I defended my choice. "He was a son of Benjamin, from Genesis."
"I'll bet Muppim got beat up a lot in school."
"Maybe, but his brother must have stuck up for him. His name was Huppim."

Eventually, well, when my wife was eight months along, my father got the clue and stopped asking what the names were going to be. Then, when Tadpole was born he was a boy. See how the Tadpole thing saved us. If we had called the baby "she", I would have had to write she was a boy. That would be confusing.

Actually, we never would have called that particular baby a "she." My wife told me early on she knew it was going to be a boy. I asked her how she knew.
"Woman's intuition," she told me.
I knew I couldn't argue with that. So I requested further information. "Has your woman's intuition generally been right before?"
"I don't know," she admitted. "This is the first time I've had it."

Tadpole did get a name, of course. And apparently it meets with my father's satisfaction. Though at that point it was too late to do anything about it, so it would have been diplomatic to tell me he liked it either way.

I don't actually care for the reader to form opinions of the name either. So I'm not going to reveal here what it was. Tadpole will serve fine. Let's just say it's not a common name. But my son might meet two or three other men with the same name on the streets of Manhattan. Well, not the one in Kansas.

Copyright 2008 Erich Goldstein

2 comments:

  1. This is amusing. I actually chuckled outloud.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Heard all this before, but it's still just as funny, maybe even more so on paper!From Becky

    ReplyDelete